2012
Spring: The New Kid On The Block

2011
Spring: Barbecuing Hamlet
Summer: To Kill A Mockingbird
Winter: Oliver!

2010
Spring: Dear Ruth
5:16 Players Spring: The Beggar and the Wolf
Summer: Little Women: A Musical
Teen Theater: Communication Breakdown
Dinner Theater: Dracula's Daughters: A Family Comedy
Winter: A Dickens' Christmas Carol: A Travelling Travesty in Two Tumultuous Acts

2009
Spring: Driving Miss Daisy
5:16 Players Spring: Down By The Creekbank
Summer: Nunsense
Dinner Theater: Death by Chocolate
Teen Theater: Star Tacks: The Exposition Menace
Winter: Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus

2008
Spring: Come Blow Your Horn
Summer: The Boyfriend
Teen Theater: The Seussification of Romeo and Juliet
Teen Theater: 15 Reasons Not to be in a Play
5:16 Players Winter: Christmas Crisis at Mistletoe Mesa
Winter: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
APC Christmas Show: Babushka's Basket

2007
Spring: The Butler Did it
5:16 Players Spring: Elijah! God's Faithful Prophet
Summer: The Music Man
Dinner Theater: Peril at Pumpernickel Pass or... To Heir is Human
Teen Theater: Goldilocks on Trial
Winter: A Christmas Story
5:16 Players Winter: Bethlehem Gulch

2006
Spring: All I Really Need to Know, I Learned in Kindergarten
5:16 Players Spring: Heroes of the Faith
Summer: Into the Woods
Dinner Theater: Someone Save My Baby Ruth or...Foil that Villian!
Winter: A Christmas Carol
5:16 Players Winter: The King is Coming
APC Christmas Show: I'll Be Home for Christmas

2005
Spring: Dearly Departed
Summer: Fiddler on the Roof
Dinner Theater: Shakespeare Goes to Gravel Gulch
Winter: It's a Wonderful Life

2004
Spring: Arsenic and Old Lace
Summer: Honk
Dinner Theater: Tongue Twisted
Winter: Annie Get Your Gun
APC Christmas Show: Return To Cricket County

2003
Spring: Faith County II: An Evening of Culture
Summer: Cheaper By The Dozen
Dinner Theater: The Scheme of the Driftless Shifter
5:16 Players: Down By The Creekbank
Winter: Narnia
APC Christmas Show: Cricket County

2002
Spring: Faith County
Summer: The Wizard of Oz
Dinner Theater: Dogsbreath Devereaux: The Dasterdly Doctor or...Nurses! Foiled Again
Winter: The Sound of Music

2001
Spring: Two By Two
Summer: Annie
Winter: A Christmas Story

2000
Spring: The Importance of Being EarnestSummer: Secret Garden
Winter: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

1999
Spring: One Foot in Heaven
Summer: The Wind in the Willows
Winter: Miracle on 34th Street

1998
Spring: Nunsense
Summer: Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
Winter: It's a Wonderful Life

1997
Winter: The Littlest Angel

1996
Winter: A Christmas Carol